Father-of-four branded 'Nazi' by transgender officer launches landmark free speech court battle
A father-of-four branded a “Nazi”, “wife beater” and a “bigot” by a transgender police officer has launched a landmark High Court challenge after a hate crime was recorded against him.
The claimant, Harry Miller, former policeman, co-founded the free-speech campaign group Fair Cop which argues that biological sex cannot be changed.
He says his views triggered a barrage of more than 800 malicious social media posts in just 11 months from transgender police constable Lynsay Watson, who was subsequently sacked for gross misconduct.
Mr Miller welcomed Ms Watson’s dismissal online, but a year later he was asked to attend a ‘voluntary’ interview about his online post and told he may be arrested if he refused to attend.
In an extraordinary twist, Mr Miller later discovered police had recorded a hate crime against him for ‘stalking involving serious alarm or distress’ without his knowledge - despite never charging him or putting this offence to him in interview.
The landmark legal challenge against the Home Secretary and Lincolnshire Police, which opens tomorrow (WED), could have far-reaching implications for freedom of speech and the reliability of official crime statistics.
He argues that including unsubstantiated allegations in official crime figures risks exaggerating the scale of hate crime, fuelling public alarm and prompting further police intervention.
Mr Miller is asking the High Court to declare the Home Office's crime recording rules unlawful and overturn Lincolnshire Police's decision to record a hate crime against him.

He argues national rules allow police to record serious crimes against individuals without properly investigating allegations or giving those accused an opportunity to defend themselves.
His solicitor James Gardner, of law firm Conrathe Gardner, said: “It's absurd - and terrifying - that members of the public can have serious crimes recorded against them without any police investigation.”
He questioned why the Home Secretary was defending a system he described as sinister.
In a damning witness statement seen by GB News, Mr Miller reveals how his ordeal left him fearing for his family's safety.
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS
- Council worker who removed protest flags at migrant camp in midnight raid handed police order
- Lib Dem councillor blames Reform’s ‘vile propaganda’ for swastika graffiti
- British Airways plane careers off taxiway at Heathrow and gets STUCK in grass ahead of takeoff

He claims Ms Watson began targeting him in February 2022, threatening his personal safety and that of his family and seeking to portray him as a woman beater and violent extremist.
In a statement given to police in December 2022, he said: “To be publicly flagged as a terrorist is horrific and devastating.”
A police disciplinary hearing subsequently found Ms Watson had accused Mr Miller of being a Nazi, a fascist and violent towards women, and alleged that he and his campaign group were terrorists.
Ms Watson was arrested in December 2022 but the Crown Prosecution Service did not pursue a prosecution.

She was sacked by Leicestershire Police in October 2023 after continuing to post abusive messages despite repeated warnings.
Her appeal against dismissal and subsequent attempts to bring a judicial review failed.
Ms Watson accepted her online conduct warranted disciplinary action but argued she had been suffering from mental illness and that her force had failed to provide the support and therapy she needed.
In October 2024, he received a call from a Lincolnshire Police detective investigating complaints made by Ms Watson.
He was told he could face arrest if he refused to attend a voluntary interview under caution.
Mr Miller said: “The effect of being accused of a criminal act, investigated by a detective sergeant, and threatened with arrest cannot be underestimated.
“That this took place at the behest of my long-term tormentor made the stress almost unbearable.”
Detectives questioned him under a section of the Online Safety Act which makes it an offence to knowingly send false information with the intention of causing more than trivial psychological or physical harm, without reasonable excuse.
Mr Miller argued that referring to Watson as biologically male was not a false statement.
Police questioned Mr Miller over another post in which he branded Watson a liar, coward and danger to women and threatened violence if approached.
Mr Miller said: “The deep sense of injustice led me to publish a forthright, uncompromising tweet which I had hoped, albeit in vain, would serve as a warning for Watson to finally back away.”
Police decided to take no further action.
But in September last year, after demanding to see information held about him by police, Mr Miller discovered a hate crime had been recorded against him.
It was an offence he says detectives had never questioned him about.
Mr Miller says police argued he had provided no credible evidence to suggest the offence had not taken place - despite never asking him about it.
Although the crime record does not amount to a conviction, Mr Miller fears it could emerge during enhanced criminal record checks, jeopardising employment prospects and opportunities to work with children or vulnerable adults.
He is also concerned it could affect the police vetting of his stepdaughter, a serving police sergeant.
A spokesperson for the Home Office said it would not comment while legal proceedings were ongoing.
Lincolnshire police declined to comment.
Our Standards: The GB News Editorial Charter
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Angry
0
Sad
0
Wow
0