Our judicial review exposed a truth every British citizen should fear

Nov 15, 2026 - 16:30
 0  0
Our judicial review exposed a truth every British citizen should fear

I thought, after almost two decades exposing institutional failures, cover-ups and the betrayal of sexually abused children, that very little could shock me anymore.

I was wrong. What I witnessed in the High Court this week was one of the most disturbing experiences of my campaigning life, if not my whole life believing in truth and justice.


For three days, Government lawyers, funded by you, the British taxpayer, fought tooth and nail to defend the indefensible... successive Governments’ failure to implement recommendations from the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA).

And their arguments were toe-curlingly horrific.



The government argued: "There is no legal obligation to implement recommendations from any public inquiry."

Promises made in Parliament do not legally bind Governments.

Failing to implement recommendations designed to protect children causes survivors “no detriment”.

Neither I nor my charity, The Maggie Oliver Foundation, has the legal standing to challenge them.


Maggie Oliver



This isn’t a legal matter. It’s a political one.

Implementing change is difficult because Governments have “so many competing priorities”.

The Government’s refusal to outlaw the use of pain compliance techniques on some of our most vulnerable children is justified because such techniques are sometimes necessary and, in any event, are used on relatively few children.

As though the fact that fewer children are subjected to such treatment somehow makes it acceptable.

These are vulnerable children, often already traumatised, who should be protected by the very institutions responsible for their care.

How can inflicting deliberate pain on even one vulnerable child be justified on the basis that it doesn’t happen very often? Just let that sink in.

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS



Baroness Casey


These are arguments advanced on behalf of our government, using our money, to fight against recommendations intended to protect our children.

I found it brutal, inhumane, and utterly shameful.

And the timing could hardly be more significant.

This week, Baroness Casey publicly also expressed her frustration at the unacceptable delays in implementing recommendations from her own grooming gangs audit, published in June 2025.

She said her patience had worn “very, very thin” and that the momentum for change simply hadn’t been good enough. I couldn’t agree more.



Baroness Casey met with me, my charity The Maggie Oliver Foundation, and a dozen survivors from across the country last year.

She heard their experiences firsthand and was visibly shocked by what they told her.

Yet here we are again, another damning report, more recommendations and more promises. And still unacceptable delays.

Meanwhile, we are fighting over recommendations dating back to 2018 and promises stemming back to Teresa May in 2014.

How many more years must pass? How many more children must suffer?



Shabana Mahmood

But what makes this Judicial Review so extraordinarily important is that we are now embarking on another national inquiry, this time into “grooming gangs”.

And I have a very serious question. If the Government’s position is that it has no legal obligation to implement recommendations from public inquiries, what exactly are they promising the survivors who will participate in this next one?

These are vulnerable people, many carrying lifelong trauma, who will once again be asked to revisit the most horrific experiences imaginable.

To relive their abuse, to reopen wounds, to trust institutions that have already failed them catastrophically.

And for what? To give them false hope that this time things will change?

What possible justification can there be for retraumatizing survivors through another expensive public inquiry if the Government can simply disregard its recommendations?


I increasingly believe public inquiries have become convenient political tools.

When public outrage becomes impossible to ignore, announce an inquiry.

Promise answers, promise lessons will be learned and promise change.

Spend millions of pounds. Publish thousands of pages.

Then quietly move on... And when someone dares to challenge that betrayal, unleash the full legal and financial might of the State against them.

As they have with my tiny charity. It is a grotesque betrayal of public trust.


Charlie Peters (left), grooming gang survivor (right)

I know personally the enormous price whistleblowers and survivors pay for speaking out.

I have personally lived with those consequences for almost 15 years.

And to hear Government lawyers argue that failing to implement promised reforms causes survivors “no detriment” was breathtakingly callous.

Tell that to the survivors sitting in that courtroom. Tell that to the families whose children were failed, or worse still, died. Tell that to those still fighting for justice decades later.


I am immensely proud that my charity, The Maggie Oliver Foundation, has had the courage to take this fight to the High Court.

We presented the strongest case we possibly could. The judge listened intently throughout, and we now await his judgment.

Ultimately, he must decide what the law permits, not simply what morality demands.

I believe this could prove to be one of the most significant Judicial Reviews in decades.

Because it exposes a question every British citizen should be asking.

If Government promises carry no legal weight, and public inquiry recommendations can be disregarded without consequence, who actually holds those in power accountable?


Maggie Oliver

We have funded this fight through public donations, while the Government has defended its position using taxpayers’ money.

If you believe in what we are doing, please support us and donate whatever you can.

Because this isn’t simply about children failed yesterday.

It’s about children being abused today. And those who will be at risk tomorrow.

Survivors deserve more than another inquiry, another apology and another broken promise.

Promises matter, trust matters and accountability matters.


And above all, children matter. The Government’s arguments in court this week left me questioning whether those in power truly understand that, or even want to.

That is why we fought. And that is why we will never give up.




What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Angry Angry 0
Sad Sad 0
Wow Wow 0