Oxford's rabid pro-Jason Arday mob will silence any view that isn't theirs

Nov 19, 2026 - 11:30
 0  0
Oxford's rabid pro-Jason Arday mob will silence any view that isn't theirs

I loathe the concept of “no-platforming”.

It’s an insidious practice which has taken hold throughout academia, politics, and public life generally.


We know how it works.

If a person’s views are deemed to be controversial or to conflict with fashionable liberal opinion, massive pressure is placed on individuals not to debate with them – or even be seen in their company.



Even those whose views are shared by many voters – such as right-wing populists and gender-critical feminists – are liable to find themselves targeted by the self-appointed censors.

In some cases, individuals can be pilloried for sharing a platform with a blacklisted person even before he or she achieved notoriety – as some who rubbed shoulders with Russell Brand and David Walliams in the past can attest.

This kind of authoritarianism may be routine in tinpot dictatorships.

But free societies should not indulge in it.


Russell Brand and David Walliams



Short of inciting law-breaking or violence, individuals should be at liberty to express their genuinely held beliefs or ideas without fear they will unpersoned or banish from the public square.

In fact, human progress has often been driven by those who, at the time, were voicing unpopular or dissenting opinions.

If everyone preached only the received wisdom, advancement would be harder to come by.

Which brings me Nathan Cofnas.

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS



Dr Nathan Cofnas


Cofnas is the American academic who was thrust into the spotlight earlier this year when he exposed Professor Jason Arday as a charlatan and plagiarist.

This naturally placed him in the crosshairs of race activists and DEI ideologues who, ignoring all the evidence, argued that Arday was the victim of a witch-hunt.

More controversial are Cofnas’s views on “race science” and hereditarianism.

He believes that variations in human traits and abilities, such as intelligence, are explained by biological – including racial – differences, rather than social factors.

He once claimed that, under a truly meritocratic system, black people would “disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment”.



I’m not qualified to know if Cofnas’s views are rooted in any firm scientific evidence.

I do know that plenty of scientists disagree with him.

I also know that it is morally wrong to treat any human less favorably on account of his or her skin colour.

But I believe that, however controversial or provocative about his position, Cofnas should be free to argue about his case.

And anyone who wishes to tell him that he is spouting garbage should be equally entitled to do so.

So, I have zero sympathy with the hundreds of protesters who, on Tuesday evening, rocked up to the University of Oxford, where Cofnas was to give a talk, and tried their damnedest to prevent the event going ahead, including by creating mass disorder, breaking down doors and scaling walls.



Oxford protests

The demonstrators – mostly students, some wearing masks – chanted the late Professor Arday’s name and waved placards in his honour.

One police officer was assaulted, and some guests were blocked from accessing the building.

Those guests had every right to attend the event and to listen to – and, if they wished, to challenge – what Cofnas had to say.

If the man’s views are as wrong-headed and unscientific as some claim, then events such as this will help to expose him.

Instead, as the university was besieged by those trying to shut him down, he ended up looking at the victim.


Universities, of all places, should be cauldrons of open discussion and debate – institutions which subject students to the widest range of competing standpoints, even ones which offend them.

It is within such environments that young people can best develop their critical thinking skills and learn how to argue cogently and convincingly.

But higher education in Britain is bedeviled with ideological conformism.

Instead of being exposed to a marketplace of ideas, students are too often shielded from opinions they may find upsetting and given “safe spaces” for their protection.


And if a view is aired that challenges their own biases, they close ranks, often supported by their own lecturers and assorted radical activists, and attempt to suppress it – invariably labelling the opinion and the person who expressed it as “fascist”.

How will students ever build up the reserves of intellectual and emotional resilience necessary to get them through life when they are cossetted so much, or when they are encouraged to form their own battalions of the thought police?

That this culture of censorship has taken root so firmly on the Left is particularly depressing.

It was, after all, the foot soldiers of the democratic Left who once fought for freedom of expression against the ranks of the establishment who were determined to enforce ideological orthodoxy.

Throughout history, the Left saw its protests put down, its dissenters thrown in jail, and occasionally guns turned upon it for daring to fight for the liberty to speak and argue freely.

That’s the tradition of the Left with which I, as an old school trade unionist, proudly identify.

But it is fast disappearing.


Now the lanyard-wearing, woke-preaching, Guardian-reading social radicals of the undemocratic liberal Left have captured large parts of the establishment and have become the new ideological gatekeepers, ruthlessly enforcing their own orthodoxies and prejudices.

It didn’t surprise me to learn that Jolyon Maugham KC of the Good Law Project, and one of Jason Arday’s biggest defenders, had given a speech at the Oxford protest and several Labour MPs had signed a petition calling for Cofnas’s talk to be cancelled.

That’s the narrow authoritarian strip on which much of the Left stands these days.

It is possible to abhor Nathan Cofnas and everything he stands for while defending his right to make his case and the right of others to hear it.

We don’t make our society more civilized or tolerant by shutting down the likes of Cofnas.

We, in fact, achieve the very opposite.




What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Angry Angry 0
Sad Sad 0
Wow Wow 0